|
|||||
|
|
||||
|
|
||||
|
|||||
|
|||||
|
|||||
Now with wheelchair symbols. As it hasn't been updated since 2015, its fallen behind in network developments: |
Now with Tweedbank. |
|||||||||||
High Speed 1 into St Pancras: Very confusing around north and east London with sharp curves running over the junctions of other lines; no Ebbsfleet - more important to Eurostar than Ashford. Thameslink into the new St Pancras station box: There appears a new line connecting St Pancras to an unnamed station on the Thameslink line. A poor attempt at relocating the Thameslink station using the symbol for a railway line. Fort William: Junction changed from correct layout to a right-angled shape - why? Settle & Carlisle line angle: The new angle of this line has no match anywhere on the map (while the final connection into Leeds is at the original angle); it also makes the connections to Lancaster and Clitheroe wrong, and where's Hellifield? What was previously correct is now wrong. Glasgow - Perth: Why straighten Glasgow - Perth when Edinburgh - Perth is an equally important route (also providing Perths direct connection to London). Chiltern line straightening: The Chiltern line is straighter but only at the expense of the Coventry connection, which is now worse for Cross Country. |
|||||||||
1 Inconsistency at junction stations. Some lines approach correctly, some approach from the wrong direction (Reading, London Bridge) and some radiate like stars (Bristol, Leeds, Leicester). 2 No indication of route options when lines cross between stations. 3 CTRL (to Waterloo) shown as a completely segregated railway when it is not. 4 Confusing (and unnecessary) geographic distortion; eg Birkenhead directly south of Liverpool when it is west just over the Mersey, Mallaig north of Fort William when it is west. 5 London and the South-East perspective: misrepresentation of Scotland in relation to England, over-large space between Yorkshire and Lancashire giving ‘strung-out’ effect. Poor use of space, map doesn’t fill width of sheet. 6 Inconsistent level of detail: Liverpool Wirral lines loop and Welsh Valleys but few Glasgow suburban lines; Walsall and Windsor but no Stratford or Pontefract; Birmingham University but no Swinton Interchange. 7 Poor cartography, lacking quality in execution, odd choice of 37.5º; strange coast line with Isle of Wight shown as a triangle when it looks like a diamond. 8 Major routes like Birmingham-Poole, South Coast etc., do not look likely routes. 9 Enlargement of the London and Birmingham networks has necessitated a bad kink into the Chiltern main line at Banbury. |
The recently seen 2008 version (on the National Rail website) has High Speed 1 (Ashford - St Pancras) crudely added on. Note 'International' unnecessarily abbreviated to 'Int.' in the key. The airport symbols have probably gone wrong and are too fine, especially compared to the over-large ship symbol. Channel Tunnel services to mainland Europe is now just 'Channel Tunnel services'. Is that a new marketing title? Where the map has failed to prevent station names crossing over lines, two conventions are used, light blue behind Nottingham but white behind Birmingham and Coventry. Oxenholme joins the gang as a result of the only other change on the map, the straightening of the Settle & Carlisle. |
||||||||